Skip to main content

Table 1 Accuracy and coverage of the present approach for predicting kinase - substrate interactions

From: Modular composition predicts kinase/substrate interactions

  

Training

Testing

  

PTM

2006

HPRD

BioGrid

PTM

2009

  

TK

S/TK

TK

S/TK

TK

S/TK

TK

S/TK

Data

EPPI

886

2925

137

199

111

166

33

237

 

Kinase

56

176

60

104

41

67

15

61

 

Substrate

274

881

32

44

26

44

21

90

 

VPPI

15344

155056

1920

4576

1066

2948

315

5490

Present

PPPI

1132

7133

43

204

36

69

27

193

 

MPPI

617

1876

18

26

17

15

6

16

 

p value

0

0

9.0 E-12

1.3E-07

1.0E-09

7.0E-07

0.014

0.0038

 

Se

69.6

64.1

13.14

13.07

15.32

0.04

18.18

6.75

 

Sp

96.6

95.4

97.76

95.54

96.62

97.66

91.43

96.48

CSSM

PPPI

14496

122975

763

1411

433

836

234

4462

 

MPPI

826

2815

84

67

64

53

26

160

 

p value

0.9416

0

3.79E-08

0.0096

4.33E-05

0.128

0.204

1

 

Se

93.23

96.24

61.31

33.67

57.66

31.93

78.79

67.51

 

Sp

5.44

20.69

60.26

69.17

59.38

71.64

25.71

18.72

K-GIDDI

PPPI

1491

1557

117

75

88

68

33

65

 

MPPI

206

42

19

6

17

5

2

11

 

p value

0

0.0098

1.32E-04

0.0432

0.0025

0.1814

0.7

0.0002

 

Se

23.25

1.44

13.87

3.02

15.32

3.01

6.06

4.64

 

Sp

90.28

99

93.9

98.36

91.74

97.69

89.52

98.81

  1. EPPI: Number of Experimental PPI; PPPI: Number of predicted PPI; MPPI: Number of matches between PPPI and EPPPI; VPPI: Number of Virtual PPI used in p value computations. Also shown is the prediction coverage and accuracy of two previously published approaches (CSSM, K-GIDDI).