Skip to main content

Table 1 Details of competing models for Clb5 data

From: Parametric modeling of cellular state transitions as measured with flow cytometry

t Criterion NMIX TMIX SNMIX STMIX STNMIX
0 ^ max 2539.78 2647.35 2682.44 2771.12 2759.40
  BIC -5033.60 -5239.55 -5300.53 -5468.69* -5445.25
  D n 0.0413 0.0262 0.0292 0.0164 0.0185
10 ^ max 1201.11 1224.87 1357.82 1405.31 1406.80
  BIC -2356.27 -2394.60 -2651.32 -2737.09 -2740.08*
  D n 0.0424 0.0284 0.0312 0.0214 0.0190
20 ^ max -5463.40 -5462.64 -4869.75 -4792.67 -4791.62
  BIC 10972.72 10980.37 9803.79 9658.80 9656.69*
  D n 0.0758 0.0715 0.0251 0.0264 0.0266
25 ^ max -7040.90 -6981.07 -6992.27 -6918.17 -6916.52
  BIC 14127.73 14017.26 14048.84 13909.82 13906.53*
  D n 0.0147 0.0145 0.0155 0.0077 0.0075
30 ^ max -7251.45 -7226.16 -7228.28 -7203.05 -7201.55
  BIC 14548.76 14507.34 14520.76 14479.46 14476.46*
  D n 0.0218 0.0175 0.0143 0.0129 0.0110
35 ^ max -6413.58 -6412.58 -6374.92 -6320.38 -6334.20
  BIC 12872.96 12880.12 12813.96 12714.04* 12741.69
  D n 0.0196 0.0230 0.0136 0.0117 0.0152
40 ^ max -4626.43 -4625.80 -4546.10 -4429.22 -4461.12
  BIC 9298.55 9306.44 9156.18 8931.56* 8995.37
  D n 0.0338 0.0306 0.0170 0.0123 0.0184
50 ^ max -1286.86 -1121.26 -1286.53 -1093.80 -1086.34
  BIC 2619.40 2297.35 2637.03 2260.70 2245.79*
  D n 0.0222 0.0145 0.0218 0.0139 0.0132
60 ^ max -2016.29 -1596.75 -1835.23 -1573.97 -1568.82
  BIC 4078.18 3248.21 3734.30 3220.89 3210.59*
  D n 0.0540 0.0203 0.0339 0.0172 0.0131
75 max ^ -8146.57 -7810.70 -7772.60 -7770.74 -7769.87
  BIC 16393.86 15731.29 15682.55* 15688.00 15686.25
  D n 0.0219 0.0119 0.0079 0.0101 0.1104
  1. Details of competing models for Clb5Δ data. Here, the notations stand for log-likelihood maxima ^ max max, BIC values, and distances D n based on Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S) test statistic. The abbreviation of models are the normal mixtures (NMIX), the t mixtures (TMIX), the skew-normal mixtures (SNMIX), the skew-t mixtures (STMIX) and the skew-t-normal mixtures (STNMIX), respectively. According to BIC and D n , the optimal selection of the STNMIX model with equal dfs is evident for most points. The smallest values of BIC and D n are indicated by * and , respectively.