Table 3 Comparisons among different methods with different image datasets in tracing accuracy
From: Neuron anatomy structure reconstruction based on a sliding filter
Data set | Size | Precision/recall | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SEF-OCS | OCS | NCT | APP | APP2 | DF | TM | ||
OP_1 | 512*512*60 | 0.97/0.91 | 0.93/0.85 | 0.86/0.79 | 0.73/0.77 | 0.92/0.93 | 0.82/0.84 | 0.83/0.87 |
OP_2 | 512*512*88 | 0.93/0.94 | 0.87/0.89 | 0.81/0.72 | 0.97/0.91 | 0.95/0.65 | 0.89/0.74 | 0.77/0.79 |
OP_3 | 512*512*62 | 0.89/0.94 | 0.85/0.92 | 0.79/0.83 | 0.94/0.92 | 0.85/0.83 | 0.91/0.96 | 0.91/0.92 |
OP_4 | 512*512*67 | 0.91/0.85 | 0.92/0.79 | 0.83/0.76 | 0.61/0.65 | 0.93/0.86 | 0.72/0.79 | 0.75/0.79 |
OP_5 | 512*512*76 | 0.93/0.94 | 0.89/0.95 | 0.86/0.81 | 0.81/0.9 | 0.85/0.87 | 0.81/0.84 | 0.79/0.81 |
OP_6 | 512*512*101 | 0.85/0.89 | 0.79/0.82 | 0.76/0.73 | 0.82/0.63 | 0.89/0.83 | 0.93/0.82 | 0.67/0.71 |
OP_7 | 512*512*71 | 0.82/0.91 | 0.84/0.86 | 0.81/0.77 | 0.75/0.88 | 0.91/0.9 | 0.91/0.86 | 0.71/0.7 |
OP_8 | 512*512*85 | 0.86/0.94 | 0.73/0.94 | 0.79/0.74 | 0.7/0.86 | 0.93/0.91 | 0.83/0.92 | 0.73/0.74 |
OP_9 | 512*512*92 | 0.91/0.92 | 0.87/0.91 | 0.85/0.81 | 0.81/0.63 | 0.83/0.85 | 0.77/0.91 | 0.7/0.69 |
NC_1 | 512*512*60 | 0.89/0.87 | 0.73/0.84 | 0.79/0.76 | 0.96/0.93 | 0.9/0.89 | 0.67/0.71 | 0.71/0.75 |
NC_2 | 512*512*33 | 0.85/0.83 | 0.81/0.89 | 0.81/0.79 | 0.91/0.93 | 0.85/0.69 | 0.87/0.61 | 0.8/0.81 |
NC_3 | 512*512*44 | 0.9/0.85 | 0.72/0.71 | 0.71/0.69 | 0.89/0.85 | 0.89/0.7 | 0.75/0.71 | 0.73/0.76 |
NC_4 | 512*512*51 | 0.93/0.92 | 0.75/0.74 | 0.67/0.65 | 0.81/0.85 | 0.83/0.87 | 0.82/0.85 | 0.74/0.75 |
NC_5 | 512*512*50 | 0.88/0.89 | 0.7/0.67 | 0.73/0.65 | 0.87/0.86 | 0.84/0.8 | 0.73/0.7 | 0.79/0.73 |
NC_6 | 512*512*46 | 0.86/0.85 | 0.9/0.79 | 0.8/0.64 | 0.87/0.89 | 0.85/0.81 | 0.82/0.75 | 0.81/0.85 |
Average | 0.89/0.9 | 0.82/0.83 | 0.79/0.74 | 0.83/0.83 | 0.88/0.82 | 0.82/0.8 | 0.76/0.78 | |