Skip to main content

Table 3 The empirical type I error rates for the six different methods (the third to ninth column): PCC, SRCC, TLSA, permutation, LSAres (AR), LSAres (ARMA), and DDLSA, based on the ARMA(1,1)-TAR(1) model

From: Statistical significance approximation for local similarity analysis of dependent time series data

ρ1,ρ2

n

PCC

SRCC

TLSA

permutation

LSAres(AR)

LSAres(ARMA)

DDLSA

-0.5 -0.5

100

0.0490

0.0509

0.0295

0.0492

0.0273

0.0292

0.0309

 

200

0.0511

0.0511

0.0369

0.0515

0.0341

0.0372

0.0387

 

300

0.0495

0.0499

0.0393

0.0529

0.0383

0.0393

0.0400

 

500

0.0511

0.0517

0.0414

0.0519

0.0388

0.0405

0.0407

 

1000

0.0493

0.0508

0.0440

0.0496

0.0401

0.0419

0.0426

0 0

100

0.0494

0.0494

0.0294

0.0502

0.0283

0.0304

0.0329

 

200

0.0532

0.0518

0.0330

0.0499

0.0323

0.0341

0.0359

 

300

0.0487

0.0466

0.0368

0.0510

0.0368

0.0360

0.0377

 

500

0.0776

0.0778

0.0841

0.0989

0.0373

0.0387

0.0445

 

1000

0.0813

0.0813

0.0901

0.1005

0.0447

0.0400

0.0454

0.3 0.3

100

0.1172

0.1121

0.0955

0.1391

0.0280

0.0321

0.0431

 

200

0.1181

0.1149

0.1191

0.1549

0.0329

0.0327

0.0438

 

300

0.1181

0.1136

0.1277

0.1557

0.0349

0.0373

0.0460

 

500

0.1135

0.1106

0.1436

0.1683

0.0411

0.0416

0.0469

 

1000

0.1186

0.1122

0.1585

0.1748

0.0430

0.0460

0.0486

0.3 0.5

100

0.1245

0.1196

0.1098

0.1586

0.0336

0.0310

0.0396

 

200

0.1369

0.1259

0.1400

0.1778

0.0315

0.0356

0.0449

 

300

0.1350

0.1275

0.1545

0.1839

0.0421

0.0390

0.0454

 

500

0.1355

0.1281

0.1690

0.1940

0.0423

0.0423

0.0466

 

1000

0.1336

0.1339

0.1823

0.2014

0.0422

0.0407

0.0518

0.5 0.5

100

0.1584

0.1527

0.1527

0.2091

0.0280

0.0347

0.0423

 

200

0.1589

0.1520

0.1827

0.2258

0.0352

0.0365

0.0433

 

300

0.1604

0.1516

0.2004

0.2391

0.0382

0.0383

0.0429

 

500

0.1545

0.1500

0.2203

0.2484

0.0358

0.0405

0.0472

 

1000

0.1601

0.1507

0.2396

0.2609

0.0422

0.0425

0.0471

0.5 0.8

100

0.2160

0.2031

0.2282

0.2985

0.0312

0.0335

0.0401

 

200

0.2157

0.2075

0.2858

0.3361

0.0351

0.0346

0.0399

 

300

0.2194

0.2064

0.3158

0.3595

0.0391

0.0367

0.0431

 

500

0.2144

0.2032

0.3221

0.3582

0.0402

0.0376

0.0444

 

1000

0.2257

0.2083

0.3643

0.3920

0.0410

0.0423

0.0506

  1. The first and second columns represent different autoregressive coefficients and number of time points, respectively. Note that we used the residuals from the estimated AR(p) or ARMA(p,q) models by maximum likelihood estimate and the order selection was based on the Akaike Information criterion (AIC). The number of permutations was 1000. The pre-specified type I error was 0.05 and the number of replications was 10000