Skip to main content

Table 4 Statistical results for the apo-structure docking conformations found by LGA, LPSO and DGLRDPSO

From: Diversity-guided Lamarckian random drift particle swarm optimization for flexible ligand docking

PDBa

Ntorb

LGA

LPSO

DGLRDPSO

NSc

MEd

LEe

NS

ME

LE

NS

ME

LE

1bcu

2

0

−3.09

–

0

−3.01

–

0

−2.77

–

1aht

7

0

−3.24

–

0

−5.05

–

0

−5.13

–

1ay6

9

1

−7.42

−8.51

0

−9.18

–

3

−9.38

−10.59

1bhx

9

1

−6.90

−8.04

0

−11.61

–

0

−11.82

–

1tom

9

5

−8.17

−9.17

18

−11.36

−12.39

15

−11.49

−11.86

1uma

9

0

−3.60

–

0

−6.36

–

0

−7.18

–

1afe

10

0

−6.02

–

1

−9.64

−9.76

2

−9.48

− 9.75

1bb0

10

5

−7.46

−8.86

2

− 12.47

−13.89

4

−12.80

−14.00

1a61

12

0

−7.14

–

0

−12.92

–

0

−13.47

–

1b5g

12

0

−7.57

–

1

−12.66

−11.59

1

−12.87

−12.36

1ba8

12

0

−5.62

–

0

−11.76

–

2

−11.80

−13.57

1a3b

13

0

−3.63

–

0

−8.48

–

0

−8.68

–

1fpc

13

0

−6.94

–

4

−11.62

−12.09

3

−11.42

−11.67

1tbz

13

1

−7.41

−9.81

2

−13.95

−13.90

4

− 13.95

−14.84

1a46

14

4

−7.35

−9.85

4

−14.23

−15.37

1

−14.53

−15.87

1ae8

14

2

−5.58

−6.88

14

−10.82

−11.17

17

−11.10

−11.63

1lhc

14

1

−6.47

−8.80

0

−11.76

–

2

−12.01

−12.89

1lhg

14

3

−5.26

−6.95

8

−10.77

−12.13

7

−11.00

−12.25

1a4w

15

0

−5.99

–

0

−13.68

–

1

−13.88

−14.69

1a5g

15

1

−7.19

−7.94

0

−13.02

–

1

−13.37

−15.05

1lhd

15

3

−5.47

−7.09

4

−10.79

−12.04

9

−11.15

− 12.27

1aix

16

1

−4.74

−6.15

2

−11.76

−11.70

2

−11.62

−12.25

1lhe

16

0

−4.30

–

1

−11.47

−12.39

2

−11.58

−12.26

1awf

25

0

2.56

–

0

−6.06

–

0

−6.42

–

Wins

4

1

1

6

3

4

11

20

13

  1. aThe PDB code of the thrombin crystallographic complex
  2. bThe number of torsions of the corresponding ligand
  3. cThe number of successful dockings
  4. dThe mean binding free energy for 30 final docking conformations
  5. eThe lowest binding free energy among all the successful docking conformations