Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of traditional and new microarray platforms with sequencing approaches

From: Unlocking the transcriptomic potential of formalin-fixed paraffin embedded clinical tissues: comparison of gene expression profiling approaches

Technology

Technology/Platform

Biochemistry

Approx. Throughput

Max. no. probes/primer pairs

No. of mapped ENSG IDs

Read Depths

Input FFPE RNA (ng)*

Approx. cost per sample (£)**

Success rate of FF samples (n)

Success rate of FFPE samples (n)

3′ RNA sequencing

Lexogen QuantSeq

RNA → RT, oligodT priming from 3′ end, random priming towards 3′ end → amplification and barcoding → sequencing

96 samples per 5 days

55,765

25,610

10 M

500

90

N/A

98% (318)

QiaSeq UPX 3′ Transcriptome

RNA → RT, oligodT priming for cDNA synthesis →template switching for 2nd strand synthesis priming → fragmentation → end repair addition, adapter ligation → PCR to add indices → sequencing

96 samples per 5 days

42,553

20,000

15 M

10

50

N/A

94% (48)

Specific Targeted Sequencing

BioSpyder TempO-Seq

RNA → annealed 50 bp detector oligos are ligated then amplified and barcoded → sequencing

192 samples per 4 days

19,300

19,300

12 M

20 μm FFPE Section

160

N/A

95% (38)

Ion Ampliseq Transcriptome

RNA → RT, multiplex PCR → sequence barcoding → emulsion PCR → sequencing of ~ 150 bp targets

96 samples per 5 days

20,802

19,059

8 M

10

160

100% (108)

76% (76)

Targeted Probes

Nanostring

RNA → hybridisation to fluorescent barcoded probes in solution → immobilised in nCounter cartridge → scan

12 samples per day (800 genes)

800

800

N/A

50

250

N/A

100% (12)

Newer Microarray

Affymetrix Clariom S

RNA → cRNA amplification → hybridisation to GeneChip → scan

192 samples per 4 days

211,300

> 20,000

N/A

50

100

100% (3)

100% (8)

Traditional Microarray

Affymetrix U133A

192 per day

250,833

11,827

N/A

50

360

100% (178)

100% (286)

Illumina BeadChip HT-12 v3 / v4

RNA → RT, amplification, biotinylation (NuGEN WT Ovation kit) → hybridisation to 50 bp probes on chip → scan

96 samples per 1.5 days

47,323

22,571

N/A

1500

195

91% (348)

21% (206)

Full RNA Sequencing

RNA-seq

RNA → fragmentation → RT → barcoded library construction → genome-wide full RNA sequencing

8 samples per 5 days

20,025

18,57s1

136 M paired reads

2000

250–500

100% (52)

100% (87)

  1. *Input RNA reflects quantities used in this study – for input ranges refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines
  2. **Estimated costs (£, UK December 2019) include library preparation and sequencing. Costs can vary by sample numbers and sequencing infrastructure