Skip to main content

Table 1 Error rates (%) of proposed SPECTRA predictor and competing methods for dataset 1

From: SPECTRA: a tool for enhanced brain wave signal recognition

Subject

CSP

CSSP

FBCSP

DFBCSP

SFBCSP

SBLFB

CSP-TSM

SPECTRA

(Proposed)

aa

21.00

 ± 5.31

17.00

 ± 7.34

17.14

 ± 8.19

9.65

 ± 5.01

18.43

 ± 7.45

16.79

 ± 8.93

16.79

 ± 6.29

10.36

 ± 6.10

al

3.86

 ± 3.63

3.07

 ± 3.03

1.29

 ± 1.18

1.00

 ± 1.91

1.64

 ± 1.36

1.36

 ± 1.23

2.14

 ± 3.53

1.07

 ± 2.51

av

28.29

 ± 7.46

28.86

 ± 7.10

30.36

 ± 8.23

31.21

 ± 8.92

29.93

 ± 6.44

28.07

 ± 8.45

24.90

 ± 9.10

21.67

 ± 5.93

aw

10.36

 ± 5.10

8.43

 ± 5.09

6.50

 ± 4.55

4.64

 ± 4.75

9.29

 ± 5.85

5.57

 ± 4.90

4.54

 ± 2.80

3.93

 ± 3.29

ay

3.86

 ± 4.11

4.29

 ± 3.75

5.07

 ± 4.68

8.21

 ± 5.06

12.79

 ± 5.96

11.00

 ± 6.03

3.21

 ± 2.53

5.71

 ± 3.94

Average

13.47

 ± 5.18

12.33

 ± 5.30

12.07

 ± 5.51

10.94

 ± 5.13

14.14

 ± 5.57

12.56

 ± 6.07

10.31

 ± 4.85

8.55

 ± 4.35

  1. The lowest error rates for each of the subjects are indicated in bold