Skip to main content

Table 1 Bias and standard deviation under high-dimensional settings (Simulation setting I): bias in the first row, and standard deviation in the second row for each scenario

From: Estimation of total mediation effect for high-dimensional omics mediators

 

\(R^2_{Mediated}\)

SOS

ab

ab (Lasso)

prop

prop (Lasso)

ratio

ratio (Lasso)

H1

0.0006

0.0013

\(-0.0084\)

\(-0.0324\)

0.0001

0.0069

\(-0.0107\)

\(-0.0231\)

(\(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}} = \mathbf{M }\))

(0.0181)

(0.0370)

(0.2846)

(0.2744)

(0.0833)

(0.0795)

(0.1161)

(0.1117)

H2

0.0146

0.0299

0.1602

\(-0.0359\)

\(-0.0493\)

0.0058

0.0075

\(-0.0212\)

(\(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}} = [\mathbf{M }, \mathbf{M }^{{(2)}}]\))

(0.0184)

(0.0375)

(0.6463)

(0.2604)

(0.1960)

(0.0777)

(0.2886)

(0.1165)

H3

0.0006

0.0053

0.0923

0.0547

\(-0.0552\)

\(-0.0520\)

\(-0.0013\)

\(-0.0315\)

(\(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}} = [\mathbf{M }, \mathbf{M }^{{(1)}}]\))

(0.0071)

(0.0653)

(0.7443)

(0.7547)

(0.2520)

(0.2495)

(0.2983)

(0.3392)

H4

0.0047

0.0095

0.1421

\(-0.0347\)

\(-0.0447\)

0.0025

0.0498

\(-0.0196\)

(\(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}} = [\mathbf{M }, noise]\))

(0.0198)

(0.0403)

(0.2613)

(0.2519)

(0.0785)

(0.0689)

(0.0982)

(0.1055)

H5

\(-0.0000\)

\(-0.0000\)

\(-0.0867\)

\(-0.3449\)

\(-0.0173\)

\(-0.0293\)

\(-0.0532\)

\(-0.2327\)

(\(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}} = \mathbf{M }\))

(0.0095)

(0.0109)

(0.0956)

(0.1618)

(0.0158)

(0.0184)

(0.0482)

(0.0295)

  1. ab: product measure; prop: proportion measure. (Lasso) indicates that the estimation is based on the Lasso regression; otherwise, it is estimated by a mixed-effect model. The true values are presented in Additional file 1: Table S2. The set of variables included in the model is denoted as \(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}}\). The set of true mediators is denoted as \(\mathbf{M} \), the set of variables associated with exposure but not with outcome is denoted as \(\mathbf {M}^{\mathbf {(1)}}\), and the set of variables associated with outcome but not the exposure is denoted as \(\mathbf {M^{(2)}}\). Variables in \(\mathbf {M}^{\mathbf {(1)}}\) and \(\mathbf {M^{(2)}}\) are non-mediators falsely included in the putative mediator set \(\hat{{\mathbf {M}}}\)