Skip to main content

Table 6 Performance on H1N1 clinical sample

From: QQ-SNV: single nucleotide variant detection at low frequency by comparing the quality quantiles

  

QQ-SNVD

QQ-SNVHS-P80 a

LoFreq

ShoRAH

V-Phaser 2

Illumina sequencer

Pair

sens.b

FPc

sens.b

FPc

sens.b

FPc

sens.b

FPc

sens.b

FPc

 GAIIx

1d

0/4

0

4/4

2

2/4

0

0/4

0

1/4

0

 GAIIx

2e

0/4

0

4/4

1

3/4

0

0/4

0

0/4

0

 GAIIx

1 + 2f

0/4

0

4/4

4

3/4

0

0/4

0

nak

nak

 MiSeq

1d

2/4

1

4/4

5

0/4

0

0/4

0

0/4

0

 MiSeq

2e

2/4

0

4/4

2

0/4

0

nak

nak

0/4

0

 MiSeq

1 + 2f

4/4

3

4/4

6

0/4

0

nak

nak

nak

nak

  

timegh

 

timegh

 

timegi

 

timegj

 

timegj

 

 GAIIx

1d

12m51s

 

12m51s

 

7m46s

 

6h1m

 

43m15s

 

 GAIIx

2e

13m5s

 

13m5s

 

7m55s

 

6h41m

 

43m6s

 

 GAIIx

1 + 2f

21m56s

 

21m56s

 

19m1s

 

2h18m

 

nak

 

 MiSeq

1d

1m11s

 

1m11s

 

26 s

 

5h46m

 

3m40s

 

 MiSeq

2e

1m23s

 

1m23s

 

24 s

 

nak

 

3m55s

 

 MiSeq

1 + 2f

2m45s

 

2m45s

 

1 m

 

nak

 

nak

 
  1. a80th percentile of the QQ-SNVHS distribution of “error” frequencies was used as frequency cutoff to decrease the number of false positives obtained with QQ-SNVHS
  2. bsens. is the percentage of SNVs as identified in [12] that were called as SNV by QQ-SNV in region 405–425 of NA gene in H1N1 BN3 sample
  3. cFP is the number of “non-variants” in [12] that were called as SNV by QQ-SNV
  4. dReads 1 of paired-end reads
  5. eReads 2 of paired-end reads (sequenced after paired-end turn)
  6. fAll paired-end reads
  7. gcomputation time in hours (h), minutes (m) and seconds (s)
  8. hWindows 7 64 bit, 8GB RAM, 3.2GHz
  9. iLinux Ubuntu 12.04.4, 57.6 GB RAM, one core (2.3GHz) used
  10. jLinux Ubuntu 12.04.4, 57.6 GB RAM, 8 cores (2.3GHz) used in parallel
  11. kNo result could be obtained for the ShoRAH/V-Phaser 2 algorithm due to failure of the ShoRAH/V-Phaser 2 software tool on our server