Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of the classification accuracies using a real-world dataset

From: A Bayesian taxonomic classification method for 16S rRNA gene sequences with improved species-level accuracy

Taxonomy Level

Method

V1V2 Region

CST = 0.8

CST = 0.5

Species

BLCA

0.570

0.716

Kraken

0.589

0.589

MEGAN

0.544

0.544

RDP

0.490

0.613

SPINGO

0.486

0.562

Genus

BLCA

0.729

0.79

Kraken

0.694

0.694

MEGAN

0.745

0.745

RDP

0.643

0.708

SPINGO

0.605

0.650

Family

BLCA

0.814

0.832

Kraken

0.777

0.777

MEGAN

0.869

0.869

RDP

0.775

0.805

SPINGO

NA

NA

  1. Each entry in the table shows the F-scores for a classifier (i.e., rows) based on all the OTU sequences in the msd16s dataset, as described in the main text. Two confidence score thresholds (CST), 0.8 and 0.5, were applied for BLCA, RDP Classifier, and SPINGO, the thresholds as in Table 1. Note that the SPINGO program does not produce family-level classification. In addition, Kraken and MEGAN do not provide any probabilistic-based parameters for evaluating the assigned taxa, thus we used their default taxonomic assignments for comparison