Skip to main content

Table 1 Benchmark comparison of ASPIC with other similar tools

From: ASPIC: a novel method to predict the exon-intron structure of a gene that is optimally compatible to a set of transcript sequences

 

ASPIC

ASAP

ASD

ACEVIEW

GENE

#introns (#novel)

#TS

#EST/splice

#introns (#ASPIC)

#TS

#introns (#ASPIC)

#TS

#introns (#ASPIC)

#TS

ABCB10

12(0)

2

12.42

12(12)

1

Not Found

 

13(12)

3

ACADM

21(1)

15

31.52

15(14)

6

Not Found

 

22(20)

14

ACTN2

23(0)

28

19.09

20(20)

1

22(22)

4

23(23)

8

ADAM15

41(4)

67

40.07

13(13)

4

29(29)

11

56(37)

25

ADAMTS4

8(0)

3

8.63

7(7)

1

8(8)

4

8(8)

3

ADORA1

13(1)

10

4.69

8(8)

4

12(12)

9

10(9)

7

ADORA3

15(13)

5

6.13

2(2)

2

Not Found

 

3(2)

3

AGL

40(1)

12

14.48

38(38)

1

Not Found

 

39(39)

10

AGRN

41(4)

21

16.98

35(32)

1

Not Found

 

45(37)

11

AGT

7(2)

17

52.86

4(3)

1

Not Found

 

9(5)

8

AHCYL1

26(4)

35

48.50

19(19)

5

19(19)

4

26(22)

13

AKR7A2

9(1)

6

73.33

6(6)

1

7(7)

2

31(8)

15

ALDH9A1

17(4)

10

39.29

11(11)

2

Not Found

 

16(13)

7

ALPL

15(0)

8

19.47

14(13)

3

13(13)

3

17(15)

9

AMPD1

14(0)

4

7.64

13(13)

1

Not Found

 

45(14)

12

ANGPTL1

6(0)

3

10.50

5(5)

1

Not Found

 

6(6)

4

ANGPTL3

6(0)

5

19.17

6(6)

2

Not Found

 

8(6)

7

ANXA9

15(1)

3

14.40

13(13)

1

14(13)

2

16(14)

6

AP4B1

18(0)

22

14.61

12(12)

1

17(16)

12

16(16)

14

APCS

2(1)

5

62.50

1(1)

1

Not Found

 

1(1)

1

ARHGEF2

32(1)

37

15.19

22(22)

3

26(25)

6

35(31)

17

ARHGEF11

47(1)

9

7.70

42(42)

2

41(40)

6

46(45)

17

ARHGEF16

14(2)

12

18.64

10(10)

1

Not Found

 

15(12)

5

ARNT

26(1)

14

11.73

20(18)

1

22(21)

3

38(26)

14

ARPC5

4(1)

2

120.75

3(3)

1

4(2)

2

6(3)

4

ARTN

8(0)

10

5.25

7(7)

4

6(6)

3

7(7)

10

ATAD3A

22(2)

10

36.41

16(16)

2

Not Found

 

58(21)

27

ATP1B1

11(2)

12

59.27

7(7)

1

10(9)

4

11(8)

10

ATP2B4

29(3)

11

8.07

22(22)

5

23(23)

3

26(26)

14

Clorf10

2(0)

1

7.00

2(2)

1

Not Found

 

2(2)

2

Clorf26

22(0)

7

7.91

17(17)

1

Not Found

 

23(22)

6

C1QB

3(1)

3

25.67

5(2)

3

5(2)

3

6(2)

5

CAPZA1

15(4)

15

68.40

11(11)

2

10(9)

3

12(11)

7

CTRC

9(1)

4

36.22

8(8)

1

Not Found

 

8(7)

3

DMRTA2

2(0)

2

1.00

1(1)

1

Not Found

 

2(2)

1

DPH2L2

12(1)

11

31.25

10(10)

7

12(11)

12

12(11)

14

EPHA2

20(1)

8

13.45

16(16)

1

17(17)

7

20(19)

8

EYA3

20(0)

9

11.40

15(15)

1

Not Found

 

21(20)

10

FBXO2

9(0)

6

13.67

9(8)

2

6(5)

3

9(8)

5

FCGR3B

7(0)

5

22.57

4(4)

1

Not Found

 

7(7)

6

FUCA1

11(3)

8

18.00

8(8)

2

Not Found

 

7(7)

2

GBP2

17(3)

8

27.82

12(12)

2

Not Found

 

26(14)

10

GMEB1

12(1)

5

16.67

9(9)

2

11(11)

3

11(11)

6

HNRPR

20(2)

38

45.70

16(15)

7

12(12)

7

21(18)

17

LGALS8

22(2)

25

16.00

12(11)

4

13(13)

4

27(19)

21

LRRN5

3(0)

3

3.00

5(3)

2

Not Found

 

5(3)

4

LYPLA2

15(0)

14

96.07

14(14)

6

Not Found

 

15(14)

14

MASP2

11(0)

5

7.00

11(11)

2

11(11)

5

11(11)

6

MOV10

35(4)

42

25.29

29(29)

7

24(23)

8

33(31)

21

NPPB

2(0)

1

30.50

2(2)

1

Not Found

 

3(2)

3

PAFAH2

18(3)

11

15.06

12(11)

2

13(13)

5

16(14)

8

PALMD

8(0)

9

35.63

7(7)

1

Not Found

 

9(8)

8

PEX10

12(1)

13

21.58

6(6)

1

10(10)

7

12(10)

11

PINK1

10(2)

15

40.20

7(7)

2

Not Found

 

9(8)

10

PTPRU

38(3)

15

12.89

20(20)

1

Not Found

 

35(35)

9

RHOC

17(3)

5

8.35

13(2)

7

15(1)

9

39(14)

31

SDC3

6(2)

5

5.33

4(3)

2

8(4)

5

9(5)

6

SDHB

11(0)

12

97.27

9(9)

3

Not Found

 

13(11)

11

SERPINC1

12(2)

7

18.75

8(8)

2

8(8)

3

16(10)

11

SFPQ

12(3)

11

74.75

9(9)

1

9(9)

3

17(9)

25

TARDBP

21(3)

20

29.38

15(13)

4

9(9)

4

18(16)

15

TCN2

13(1)

10

26.15

9(9)

2

12(12)

4

13(10)

11

TOR3A

15(2)

9

19.20

9(9)

4

11(11)

8

15(13)

12

VAMP3

5(0)

3

80.60

6(5)

2

6(5)

3

7(5)

10

Total

1009(94)

11.9

28.3

753(721)

2.3

495(461)

5.1

1194(905)

9.7

  1. ASPIC results from a random sample of 64 human genes from Chromosome 1 compared to those from the ASAP, ASD and AceView resources. The first column reports the HUGO name of the examined gene. The ASPIC data include the total number of predicted introns (novel introns in brackets), the minimum number of compatible transcripts and the average number of ESTs supporting gene splices. Introns with 2 non canonical splices are accepted by ASPIC only if confirmed by at least two ESTs. For the other resources the number of predicted introns (in brackets those also predicted by ASPIC) and the minimum number of compatible transcripts are reported. Other resources: AceView (July 2003 and August 2004 releases), ASD (July 2004) and ASAP (July 2004).