Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of methods

From: Strategies for measuring evolutionary conservation of RNA secondary structures

Category

Methods

Description

References

Methods based on folding energies

SCI

RNAalifold consensus energy normalized by dividing by the average energy of the single sequences folded independently.

[7]

 

SCI RN Aeval

Evaluation of energies of sequences under the constraint of being forced to fold into the structures of the other sequences in comparison to the unconstrained energies.

this work

Methods based on single structures

Base-pair distance

Number of base-pairs not shared by two structures.

[64]

 

Mountain metric

Distance as the difference of two mountain functions, which give the number of base-pairs enclosing a position.

[40]

 

Tree editing

Based on the representation of RNA secondary structures as trees. A distance is deined as the cost of transforming one tree into the other.

[41-43]

Methods considering the entire folding space

Ensemble distance

Base-pair distance extended to compare ensembles of structures.

this work

 

Ensemble mountain metric

Distance as the difference of two mountain functions, which give the number of base-pairs that are, on average, expected to enclose a position.

[47]

 

RNApdist like distance

Distance measure based on the comparison of vectors of probabilities of being paired upstream, paired downstream, and unpaired.

[33,48]

 

RNAshapes

Similarity measure based on probabilities of abstract shapes.

[49]

Other Methods

ddbRNA

Evaluates compensatory mutations in all possible stem loops in all sequences of an alignment.

[9]

 

MSARi

Evaluation of the statistical significance of short, contiguous potential base-pair regions under different distribution models.

[8]