Skip to main content

Table 2 Performances of single-task models

From: CollaboNet: collaboration of deep neural networks for biomedical named entity recognition

Model

Habibi et al. (2017) STM

Wang et al. (2018) STM

Our STM

Dataset

Precision

Recall

F1 Score

Precision

Recall

F1 Score

Precision

Recall

F1 Score

NCBI-disease

85.31

83.58

84.44

84.95

82.92

83.92

83.95

85.45

84.69 (±0.54)

JNLPBA

74.83

79.82

77.25

69.60

74.95

72.17

72.51

82.98

77.39 (±0.24)

BC5CDR-chem

92.57

88.77

90.63

*93.05

*86.87

*89.85

94.02

91.50

92.74 (±0.47)

BC5CDR-disease

84.19

82.79

83.49

*84.09

*81.32

*82.68

82.98

82.25

82.61 (±0.25)

BC4CHEMD

87.83

85.45

86.62

90.53

87.04

88.75

90.50

85.96

88.19 (±0.23)

BC2GM

77.50

78.13

77.82

81.11

78.91

80.00

79.70

77.47

78.56 (±0.38)

Macro Average

83.71

83.09

83.38

83.89

82.00

82.90

83.94

84.27

84.03

  1. Our STM achieved the best performance on 3 datasets among 6. Scores in the asterisked (*) cells are obtained in the experiments that we conducted; these scores are not reported in the original papers. The best scores from these experiments are in bold