Skip to main content

Table 3 The EF values of virtual screening four targets in DUD-E dataset

From: Parallel multi-swarm cooperative particle swarm optimization for protein–ligand docking and virtual screening

  EF (%) ampc cp3a4 cxcr4 kif11 Mean
Vina 1 0 3.593 0 24.14 6.933
2 0 2.695 0 18.53 5.307
5 0 2.156 0.5 10.69 3.337
PSO-c4 1 0 3.593 2.5 24.14 7.558
2 1.042 2.096 1.25 17.67 5.515
5 0.833 1.796 0.5 11.03 3.541
PSOVina 1 0 1.796 2.5 19.83 6.031
2 1.042 1.796 1.25 12.93 4.255
5 0.417 1.796 0.5 9.31 3.006
GWOVina 1 0 3.593 0 25.86 7.364
2 0 2.695 0 18.97 5.415
5 0.417 2.275 1 10.69 3.596
MPSOVina 1 0 4.192 0 28.45 8.16
2 0 2.395 1.25 18.97 5.653
5 0.833 2.036 0.5 10.86 3.558
MRDPSO-c4 1 0 2.994 0 24.14 6.783
2 0 2.395 1.25 16.81 5.114
5 0.833 1.916 0.5 10.52 3.442
MRDPSOVina 1 0 3.593 0 27.59 7.795
2 0 2.695 1.25 18.53 5.62
5 0.417 2.156 0.5 11.03 3.527