Skip to main content

Table 10 Comparison of DTIOG variants versus other DTI competitor prediction methods

From: Advancing drug–target interaction prediction: a comprehensive graph-based approach integrating knowledge graph embedding and ProtBert pretraining

Classifiers

AUPR

AUC

ACC

MCC

F1

GPCR

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-COS

0.948

0.978

0.968

0.926

0.945

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-ED

0.963

0.985

0.978

0.948

0.961

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-MD

0.959

0.983

0.976

0.943

0.958

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-JCC

0.958

0.983

0.975

0.941

0.956

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-PCC

0.956

0.982

0.974

0.938

0.954

DTIOG-DT-KGE-COS

0.968

0.987

0.981

0.955

0.967

DTIOG-DT-KGE-ED

0.967

0.987

0.981

0.954

0.966

DTIOG-DT-KGE-MD

0.966

0.986

0.980

0.952

0.965

DTIOG-DT-KGE-JCC

0.966

0.986

0.980

0.953

0.965

DTIOG-DT-KGE-PCC

0.965

0.986

0.980

0.951

0.964

DTIOG-DT-FP-COS

0.953

0.980

0.971

0.933

0.950

DTIOG-DT-FP-ED

0.951

0.980

0.971

0.931

0.949

DTIOG-DT-FP-MD

0.953

0.981

0.972

0.934

0.951

DTIOG-DT-FP-JCC

0.954

0.981

0.972

0.933

0.951

DTIOG-DT-FP-PCC

0.957

0.982

0.974

0.940

0.955

iGRLDTI

0.954

0.979

0.944

0.850

0.885

DTI-HeNE

0.948

0.945

0.972

0.923

0.939

ALADIN

0.516

0.795

0.970

0.381

0.298

BLM-NII

0.476

0.834

0.970

0.297

0.189

IC

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-COS

0.965

0.983

0.976

0.948

0.963

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-ED

0.972

0.986

0.981

0.959

0.971

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-MD

0.973

0.987

0.982

0.961

0.972

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-JCC

0.969

0.985

0.979

0.954

0.968

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-PCC

0.968

0.985

0.979

0.953

0.967

DTIOG-DT-KGE-COS

0.972

0.987

0.982

0.959

0.971

DTIOG-DT-KGE-ED

0.977

0.989

0.985

0.967

0.977

DTIOG-DT-KGE-MD

0.976

0.988

0.984

0.965

0.975

DTIOG-DT-KGE-JCC

0.973

0.987

0.982

0.961

0.973

DTIOG-DT-KGE-PCC

0.972

0.986

0.982

0.959

0.971

DTIOG-DT-FP-COS

0.959

0.980

0.973

0.940

0.958

DTIOG-DT-FP-ED

0.962

0.981

0.974

0.944

0.960

DTIOG-DT-FP-MD

0.961

0.981

0.973

0.942

0.959

DTIOG-DT-FP-JCC

0.960

0.981

0.973

0.941

0.959

DTIOG-DT-FP-PCC

0.962

0.982

0.975

0.944

0.961

iGRLDTI

0.973

0.980

0.931

0.861

0.921

DTI-HeNE

0.981

0.978

0.986

0.964

0.973

ALADIN

0.803

0.913

0.965

0.757

0.751

BLM-NII

0.786

0.930

0.965

0.763

0.762

ENZ

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-COS

0.963

0.994

0.990

0.957

0.961

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-ED

0.971

0.996

0.993

0.967

0.970

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-MD

0.973

0.996

0.993

0.969

0.972

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-JCC

0.962

0.994

0.990

0.956

0.961

DTIOG-DT-PRTB-PCC

0.962

0.994

0.990

0.956

0.961

DTIOG-DT-KGE-COS

0.976

0.996

0.994

0.972

0.975

DTIOG-DT-KGE-ED

0.976

0.996

0.994

0.973

0.976

DTIOG-DT-KGE-MD

0.976

0.996

0.994

0.972

0.975

DTIOG-DT-KGE-JCC

0.975

0.996

0.993

0.971

0.974

DTIOG-DT-KGE-PCC

0.975

0.996

0.994

0.971

0.974

DTIOG-DT-FP-COS

0.954

0.993

0.988

0.947

0.952

DTIOG-DT-FP-ED

0.951

0.992

0.987

0.943

0.948

DTIOG-DT-FP-MD

0.956

0.993

0.989

0.949

0.954

DTIOG-DT-FP-JCC

0.955

0.993

0.988

0.948

0.953

DTIOG-DT-FP-PCC

0.955

0.993

0.988

0.948

0.953

iGRLDTI

0.949

0.940

0.885

0.760

0.906

DTI-HeNE

0.963

0.962

0.992

0.954

0.957

ALADIN

0.757

0.896

0.990

0.665

0.620

BLM-NII

0.769

0.925

0.990

0.702

0.666

  1. The best results are indicated in bold concerning each row